I think part of the $$$ problems for this site is they pay too much for colocation/dedicated, whichever they use. Nowdays, for $89.00USD/month, you can get a P4 2.4/512/80GB dedicated with 1,000GB of bandwidth from a reputable data center with multiple peers setup on bgp4. That should be more than adequate for this site. Data centers are always dropping in price, so if you negotiated your contract a long time ago, it's definitely worth your while to renegotiate your pricing.
1.0 Pastel Ball Python, 1.9 Normal Ball Pythons, 0.1 African House Snake, 1.0 Savannah Monitor, 0.0.1 Argentinian Horned Frog