You have shop around. I drive a 2003 Dodge minivan and 98 sunfire. My wife and i are both insured full coverage on both.
We pay 50$/mth. I wrote off a brand new truck a few years back and i have lots of speeding tickets and a paint job claim when my car was keyed in GTA. Shop around or get a broker. Your crazy to pay for insurance that adds up to more than the car.
Add it up and it would probley bew cheaper to taxi it.