Frankly I believe you two involved with music are correct, but I do not believe it's right to prosecute a 12 year old girl for doing something that MILLIONS of people do, will continue to do and are doing right this second. Its ludacris. No one likes record companies now, no one wants to pay 25 for a CD with one good song on it.
It's time for music to go back to the good old days, when real bands were made from OUTSTANDING live pre-formances that people PAID to get in to no problem and wanted to see again and again, wicked tunes and lots of airplay. Not a 25 dollar CD with crappy tunes on half.