Fair enough! I didn't think your comments were wrong - I just wanted to know why. I'm not going to school to be a graphic desinger, I'm going for animation.
I personally still don't think it looks too cartoony though. And not just because I drew it. If they asked for it, I could have drawn them a detailed, lifelike down the last scale drawing. But they wanted this style.
And just because it's animated doesn't mean it's for kids...but I'll spare you that rant.